The White House is scrambling tonight after a federal judge tossed out the criminal case against Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran immigrant whose prosecution had become a flashpoint for immigration hawks. Sources confirm that Judge Martha V. Gonzales of the District of Columbia granted the motion to dismiss late this afternoon, citing prosecutorial misconduct and a pattern of evidence suppression that she described in her ruling as 'an affront to the court's integrity.'
The ruling is a stinging rebuke to the Department of Justice, which had charged Garcia with illegal re-entry after deportation – a crime that carries up to two years in prison. But internal emails uncovered by this reporter show that federal prosecutors had for months sat on exculpatory documents, including asylum applications and witness statements, that would have bolstered Garcia's claim that he fled death threats from MS-13. A former DOJ official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because of fear of reprisal, told me: 'The case was toxic from the start. Someone in the chain of command wanted a scalp, and they didn't care whose.'
Garcia's lawyer, Maria Estrada, said outside the courthouse: 'My client has been subjected to almost a year of unlawful detention. The government knew he was a victim, not a criminal, and they pursued this case anyway.' Estrada added that she will now pursue a claim for damages under the Federal Tort Claims Act.
The White House, already reeling from a series of immigration-related legal defeats, tried to spin the dismissal as a procedural matter. Press Secretary Kayleigh Hicks told reporters: 'The President is committed to enforcing our immigration laws, and we respect the judicial process.' But behind the scenes, sources say the administration is furious. A senior adviser to the President, who declined to be named, told me: 'This is a disaster. We had a clean conviction in the bag, and now the whole thing blows up. Someone is going to pay for this.'
The ruling has immediate and far-reaching consequences. Garcia, who has been held at the privately run Northlake Detention Center in Louisiana, is expected to be released within 48 hours. Immigration advocates have already set up a fund for his resettlement, and at least two Democratic senators have called for a formal inquiry into the DOJ's handling of the case.
But the story doesn't end there. Uncovered documents show that the decision to prosecute Garcia was made at a high level within the Executive Office for Immigration Review. One internal memo, marked CONFIDENTIAL, instructs prosecutors to 'pursue all available criminal charges' against Salvadoran nationals with MS-13 ties – even when those ties are tenuous or, as in Garcia's case, based on mistaken identity. The memo bears the initials of a senior official who previously worked as a lobbyist for private prison companies.
Tonight, the political fallout is just beginning. Expect a flood of subpoenas, a lot of finger-pointing, and more lies from people who believe they are above the law. I'll be following the money and the bodies.
Contact this reporter with documents, tips, or rumours at the usual secure channels.
